Cinnamon Lake, OH Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Village Cornerstone Restaurant $$ 21 reviews New American, Pizza (419) 853-4885 180 E Byckeye StWest Salem, OH 44287 Cruisers $ 1 reviews Comfort Food, Barbeque, Breakfast & Brunch (419) 928-1136 360 County Rd 620West Salem, OH 44287 58 Shake and Pizza Shack image/svg+xml $ 8 reviews Pizza (419) 736-2658 229A State Route 58Sullivan, OH 44880 Subway image/svg+xml $ 3 reviews Sandwiches (419) 853-4477 8 S Main StWest Salem, OH 44287